Your cyber insurance renewal: the questions that catch organisations out

By October 26, 2026Articles
Your cyber insurance renewal: the questions that catch organisations out

At a glance

Cyber insurance renewal should be based on evidence of the controls actually in place. Check MFA coverage, backup isolation and restore tests, unsupported software, and any policy requirements for patching and incident notification. Inaccurate answers or unmet conditions can affect cover, depending on the policy and circumstances. Begin the review early with your IT provider and broker, and confirm who must be contacted during an incident.

Why renewal answers need evidence

Cyber insurance proposal forms have become considerably more demanding, and they are no longer a formality completed by whoever has a spare afternoon. The answers form part of the information the insurer relies on when arranging cover. Inaccurate disclosures or unmet policy conditions can affect a claim, depending on the policy wording and circumstances. Your broker should explain the disclosure requirements and conditions that apply.

Where the gaps usually appear

Multi-factor authentication is the most common. A form asks whether MFA is enforced for all remote access and administrative accounts. The answer given is yes; the reality is that several service accounts, an account used to access a shared mailbox and a legacy application were exempted years ago and never revisited.

Backups are the second. The question asks whether backups are held offline or immutable and tested regularly. Many organisations have backups that are none of these things, and have never performed a full restore test.

The third is end-of-life software. A single unsupported server, quietly running a business-critical application, can sit outside a policy condition without anyone in the finance or executive team knowing it exists.

Conditions that bite after the event

Depending on the policy, cover may be subject to specific conditions: patching critical vulnerabilities within a stated period, notifying the insurer within a short window of discovering an incident, and using the insurer’s own appointed response panel rather than your usual IT provider.

That last point catches people out during an incident, when the instinct is to call the people you know. Engaging your own forensics firm before notifying the insurer can jeopardise cover.

Making the renewal work for you

Treat the proposal form as a free security audit. The questions can identify controls worth reviewing, although a proposal form does not replace a complete security assessment.

Complete it with your IT provider in the room, evidencing rather than assuming each answer. Start eight weeks before renewal so that gaps can be closed rather than declared. And read the conditions to the board, not just the premium. Knowing in advance who must be called first is worth rehearsing.

How KCS can help

KCS helps clients complete cyber insurance proposals accurately, evidencing each control and flagging the gaps that need closing before renewal rather than after a claim. We also align technical controls to the conditions in your policy and help you identify gaps to discuss with your broker before renewal.

KCS provides IT support and cyber security services to commercial and charitable organisations across the UK, and we hold ISO 27001 and ISO 9001 certification.

To review the technical evidence behind your cyber insurance renewal, call the KCS team on 0330 236 6510 for an initial conversation at no cost.

About the author

Dan Gregor is a Director at KCS, a leading IT support and cyber security company. He has over thirty years’ experience in IT, including eighteen in leadership roles, and advises commercial and charity sector boards on IT strategy, cyber resilience and Microsoft technology.

Share